Photo by Katie Yu/The CW
THE FLASH: 4.10 “The Trial of the Flash”
Last night’s episode of the The Flash brought Barry Allen face to face with a judge after being arrested for the murder of DeVoe. We know before the break that this was all DeVoe’s plan, and Barry made the very difficult decision not to use his powers to run.
I didn’t make note of the episode title until after the episode started, so I was surprised that last night’s episode would bring us to the trial already. There was no real aftermath of seeing Barry taken away, seeing Iris and Joe respond, any sort of arguments against what was happening. We got right to the point where we find out Barry’s fate by the episode’s end.
I was invested in the trial as I watched the episode, though in retrospect, many nitpicks have come to mind, and I now see a number of issues with the episode. I don’t normally write about The Flash (though I do usually live tweet it, if you follow me on Twitter), but I thought I’d air out some concerns here.
First, the meta of the week. We have to remember that while many of us were tuning in to the the trial of Barry Allen, we’re watching a superhero show. Not every viewer wants to see such human events as the justice system in action. Plus, with a large cast of talented people, what do we do with Caitlin, Cisco, and Harry, rather than leaving them sitting on a bench watching the trial? Enter our nuclear meta.
The problem here is I was not in the least interested in seeing what happened with this meta—which is especially unfortunate, given that the meta could actually cause a nuclear event that would decimate the city, if not the globe. This is a pretty high-stakes villain (even if he wasn’t aware of his own power) to shove in the background of another bigger plot.
As strange as it sounds, I would have argued for no meta B-plot. Just focus on the trial. Sure, by cutting Barry’s final act of heroism before being placed behind bars, we might not get that great juxtaposition of speeches between the police chief and the judge. But we would have a lot more time to devote to other trial-related plot points, like more time with DeVoe. Or Joe’s decision to do whatever it takes to keep Barry from prison, including planting evidence (by the way, the scene between Joe and Ralph was so good it was worth having Ralph added to the series, even if I haven’t been a fan of Ralph in previous episodes). They could have done something more interesting with Cisco and Caitlin (I have a suggestion below). And more importantly, they could have presented a legal defense for Barry.